IHS Inc. The Source for Critical Information and Insight
Aero - Defense |  Change

Advanced Search
 
 

GAO: US-VISIT Not Meeting Expectations, Program Management Challenges Need to Be Addressed

February 24, 2007 // Published as a news service by IHS

After spending almost four years and more than $1B, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) implemented entry capabilities at most ports of entry, however, it has not implemented a biometric exit capability or a suitable alternative, according to a report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO).

As of December 2006, U.S. Visitor and Immigrant Status Indicator Technology (US-VISIT) deployed and was operating entry capability at 115 airports, 14 seaports and 154 of 170 land ports of entry.

However, the GAO report said the implementation of a biometric land exit capability is not feasible, according to program officials, because the only proven technology available would require additional staffing and infrastructure demands and cause delays with potential impacts on trade and commerce.

Also, testing and analysis of a non-biometric solution identified numerous performance and reliability problems and such an alternative technology does not meet legislative requirements, according to the report. The DHS believes that advances over the next five to 10 years will allow solutions that do not require major infrastructure changes, but the prospects for such technology are uncertain.

The report said the DHS continues to face longstanding US-VISIT management challenges and future uncertainties including:

  • For almost four years, the DHS continued to pursue US-VISIT without producing the program's operational and technological context. According to program officials, an immigration and border management strategic plan was drafted in March 2005 to show how US-VISIT is aligned with the DHS's organizational mission and to define an overall immigration and border management vision.

    After almost two years, this plan has not yet been approved, but the acting director said that it is currently with the U.S. Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for approval. At the same time, the DHS launched other major security programs without defining the relationship between US-VISIT and these programs.

  • The DHS has yet to economically justify its investment in US-VISIT increments or assess their operational impacts. For more than three years, the GAO reported that the program did not adequately assess the increment's costs and benefits because the assessments were unclear and insufficient and the cost estimates upon which they were based did not meet key criteria for reliable cost estimating.

    The GAO further reported that the program had not assessed the impact of the entry and exit capabilities on operations and facilities, in part, because the scope of the evaluations performed were too limited.

  • The DHS has not implemented key acquisition and financial management controls. For example, the GAO reported that the program had not effectively overseen contract work performed on its behalf by other DHS and non-DHS agencies and these agencies did not always establish and implement effective contract oversight activities.

  • Without these management controls, there is greater risk that US-VISIT will not produce the right solution and be managed the right way. Accordingly, the GAO said it made numerous recommendations to address these management challenges.

The DHS is investing billions of dollars in its US-VISIT program to collect, maintain and share information on selected foreign nationals who enter and exit the U.S. The program uses biometric identifiers including digital fingerscans and photographs to screen people against watch lists and to verify that a visitor is the person who was issued a visa or other travel document. The program is also to biometrically confirm the individual's departure.

Given where US-VISIT is today and the challenges and uncertainties associated with where it is going the GAO said it believes that the DHS is long overdue in demonstrating that it is pursuing the right US-VISIT solution and that it is managing US-VISIT the right way.

=Source: U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO).

AEROSPACE & DEFENSE ENGINEERING STANDARDS NEWS
August 25, 2008
ABI: Security Biometrics Spending to Reach $7.3B in 2013
According to ABI Research, broad interest and investment in an array of biometrics technologies around the world will drive biometrics spending ... more
August 15, 2008
EC Publishes Aviation Security Rules
On August 8, the European Commission (EC) decided to make the majority of rules relating to aviation security available to the public. ... more
August 14, 2008
DHS Releases National Emergency Communications Plan for Emergency Responders
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) released the National Emergency Communications Plan (NECP) to help address gaps and determine ... more
August 13, 2008
ASIS Int'l to Develop Business Continuity Management, Risk Assessment Standards
ASIS International will develop a business continuity management standard based on the ASIS Business Continuity Guideline and a risk assessment ... more
August 13, 2008
ASIS Int'l Issues Draft Guideline for Facilities Physical Security Measures
The ASIS Commission on Standards and Guidelines released a draft of the Facilities Physical Security Measures Guideline. ... more
Show All..